The cherry war will indeed take place

No more clafoutis, no more compote filled with sun-drenched cherries on garden tables this summer. No more baskets of cherries on the market stalls. Of course we may still find some, but at 50 € or even more... Cherries almost as expensive as caviar, it's coming soon. The reason? A small gnat, the fruit fly... suzukiiOn the one hand, an insecticide, Dimethoate, on the other hand, and finally a pitched battle between arboriculturists, the government and the European Commission. Latest news from a symptomatic illustration of the difficulties in reconciling traditional agriculture, public health and the economy.
Adrosophila suzukii is a small midge of barely 2mm, recently arrived in France in 2010, and has the unfortunate habit of attacking red fruits, especially cherries. It reproduces at lightning speed and a cloud of these bugs is capable of wiping out the entire production of an orchard. Aggravating circumstance, the midges attack when the fruit is very ripe, ready for harvest. It does so all the more as the climate is mild, which is particularly the case in our times of global warming.

The fatal weapon

Until now, there was a lethal weapon against the suzikii. An organophosphate insecticide, Dimethoate. It's radical to protect cherries from this voracious parasite. But it's dangerous to humans, birds and mammals. It would attack the central nervous system and the bloodstream. This product therefore raised legitimate concerns as early as 2012, particularly in Canada. In France, the ANSES - our food safety agency - wanted to find out for sure. In 2013, Europe, in turn, was concerned about it. And then last year, it was Paris that closed the file without waiting for the European decision, which is always very long in its procedures. The French government has come to the firm conclusion that this product is too dangerous for public health and the environment. Since February 1st, arboriculturists are no longer authorized to treat their cherry trees with this insecticide.

Bankruptcy announced

The problem is that it has been a very mild winter and our cherry trees are threatened. Arborists say they have no other weapon than Dimethoate to fight the damn gnat. According to them, there are a few other alternative chemical molecules that are still authorized, such as spinosins or cyantraniliprole, but they are not very effective and cost 8 to 10 times more than Dimethoate.
The other solution, which consists of placing anti-fly nets on fruit trees, is considered unrealistic because it is very expensive: EUR 20 to 30 000 per hectare.
Farmers are distraught: " We're in danger of going bankrupt. The state has granted my son the right to settle down but does not give him the means to fight against the suzukii drosophila. ", François Soubeyran of the FDSEA Ardèche told AFP. Its 20 hectares of cherry trees account for 96% of its income.
The situation is all the more dramatic because farmers are afraid that foreign cherries will arrive on the market this summer at lower prices because they are not affected by the ban on Dimethoate. 

Arm wrestling

Faced with this situation, and seeing no other way out than to cut down their trees with chainsaws (which some arboriculturists in the Luberon have already started to do last week), farmers are asking for a moratorium: permission to use Dimethoate a little more to treat this month's production this year.
The government, in the person of Agriculture Minister Stéphane Le Foll, has decided otherwise. Asserting that it is a matter of preserving the economic interests of producers while protecting the consumer, it has asked the European Commission to ban Dimethoate as a matter of urgency throughout the EU, as well as the marketing of cherries from countries or Member States in which the insecticide is authorised.
The Minister gives a seven-day ultimatum to the European Commission; without a response from him, France will launch a safeguard procedure.
That's what happened on Friday. France got no response from Brussels. The minister has therefore decided to ban the import of dimethate-treated cherries outright. This type of measure is triggered very rarely, which underlines its exemplary nature.
France had referred the matter to the European Commission since 1 January March to ban this molecule in order to avoid any distortion of competition between European producers. Italy and Spain have already banned the product, but other producing countries are still using it. Faced with this request, the Commission referred the matter to EFSA, the European Food Safety Authority. But the latter, as usual subject to intense pressure from industrial chemical lobbies, once again kicked the ball, claiming that there was "no data" on the effects of this molecule on consumer health.
" Dimethoate reflects very explicitly that there is a cost problem in getting out of pesticides. ", Emmanuel Aze of the Confédération paysanne told AFP. This organisation is therefore asking for partial coverage of the losses and a national aid plan to finance the installation of the nets.
This solution is, understandably, a temporary measure that cannot last. The crux of the matter is to measure how farmers will manage to move away from the farming methods they have become accustomed to in order to meet the demands of intensive consumption and distribution. Wanting a healthy diet will not only involve protection or safeguard measures; it will necessarily involve questioning production habits and, consequently, our consumption habits. 

Nous avons un message pour vous…

Dès sa création, il y a plus de dix ans,  nous avons pris l’engagement que UP’ Magazine accordera au dérèglement climatique, à l’extinction des espèces sauvages, à la pollution, à la qualité de notre alimentation et à la transition écologique l’attention et l’importance urgentes que ces défis exigent. Cet engagement s’est traduit, en 2020, par le partenariat de UP’ Magazine avec Covering Climate Now, une collaboration mondiale de 300 médias sélectionnés pour renforcer la couverture journalistique des enjeux climatiques. En septembre 2022, UP’ Magazine a adhéré à la Charte pour un journalisme à la hauteur de l’urgence écologique.

Nous promettons de vous tenir informés des mesures que nous prenons pour nous responsabiliser à ce moment décisif de notre vie. La désinformation sur le climat étant monnaie courante, et jamais plus dangereuse qu’aujourd’hui, il est essentiel que UP’ Magazine publie des rapports précis et relaye des informations faisant autorité – et nous ne resterons pas silencieux.

Notre indépendance éditoriale signifie que nous sommes libres d’enquêter et de contester l’inaction de ceux qui sont au pouvoir. Nous informerons nos lecteurs des menaces qui pèsent sur l’environnement en nous fondant sur des faits scientifiques et non sur des intérêts commerciaux ou politiques. Et nous avons apporté plusieurs modifications importantes à notre expression éditoriale pour que le langage que nous utilisons reflète fidèlement, mais sans catastrophisme, l’urgence écologique.

UP’ Magazine estime que les problèmes auxquels nous sommes confrontés dans le cadre de la crise climatique sont systémiques et qu’un changement sociétal fondamental est nécessaire. Nous continuerons à rendre compte des efforts des individus et des communautés du monde entier qui prennent courageusement position pour les générations futures et la préservation de la vie humaine sur terre. Nous voulons que leurs histoires inspirent l’espoir.

Nous espérons que vous envisagerez de nous soutenir aujourd’hui. Nous avons besoin de votre soutien pour continuer à offrir un journalisme de qualité, ouvert et indépendant. Chaque abonnement des lecteurs, quelle que soit sa taille, est précieux. Soutenez UP’ Magazine à partir d’1.90 € par semaine seulement – et cela ne prend qu’une minute. Merci de votre soutien.

Je m’abonne →

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Coca Cola
Previous article

Coca-Cola France finances science... to better sell its soft drinks...

blue white heart
Next article

Bleu Blanc Coeur: a nutrition and health-oriented agriculture

Latest articles in Food Security and Agrostrategies



Already registered? I'm connecting

Inscrivez-vous et lisez three articles for free. Recevez aussi notre newsletter pour être informé des dernières infos publiées.

→ Register for free to continue reading.



You have received 3 free articles to discover UP'.

Enjoy unlimited access to our content!

From $1.99 per week only.